Project Evaluation and Selection in Technology Development Funds with Best-Worst Method (Case Study: Innovation and Prosperity Fund)

Document Type : Research Paper


1 Ph.D. Candidate, Department of Science and Technology Policy, School of Progress Engineering, Iran University of Science and Technology, Tehran, Iran.

2 , Assistant Prof., Department of Industrial Engineering, Iran University of Science and Technology, Tehran, Iran.

3 Associate Prof., Department of Mechanical Engineering, School of Mechanical Engineering, Kashan University, Kashan, Iran


Objective: Technology Development Funds (TDFs) are one of the most important innovations and so financing institutions must prioritize identifying and funding technological projects, due to the limitation of financial resources. The objective of this paper is to present a Multi-Criteria Decision-Making model (MCDM) for evaluation and selection of appropriate projects in TDFs and their resource allocation.
Methods: In this paper a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods is used. In the first step, important criteria for evaluating technological projects are identified by reviewing literature, reviewing documents and interviewing experts and by using the factor analysis method, the most important criteria in evaluating knowledge-based projects are determined. Then a multi-criteria decision-making model based on the Best-Worst Method (BWM) is presented considering financial, firm, technology, and market analysis and risk criteria.
Results: In this study, the results of the evaluation of 20 knowledge-based projects of the applicant for the interest-free loans and industrial production loans from the Innovation and Prosperity Fund (IPF) are presented. The results of the study indicate that the weight of the evaluation criteria has a significant effect on the results of the evaluation and the approval or rejection of projects.
Conclusion: A multi-criteria decision-making model based on the Best-Worst Method is presented in this study, that by using it, technology development funds can carefully evaluate the technological projects and accurately allocate limited national financial resources to the best projects. Knowledge-based companies can also focus their strategies and initiatives on critical and important issues, considering important criteria in the evaluations.


Abbasianjahromi, H., Rajaie, H. (2012). Developing A Project Portfolio Selection Model for Contractor Firms Considering the Risk Factor. Journal of Civil Engineering and Management, 18(6), 879–889.
Abbassi, M., Ashrafi, M., Kheirkhah, A.S., Bonyad, H. & Ghorbanzadeh Karimi, H. (2013). R&D Project Portfolio Selection by Developing a Hybrid DEA-BSC Model. Journal of Science & Technology Policy, 5(3), 67-82. (in Persian)
Agha, S.R., Jarbo, M.H., Matr, S.J. (2013). A Multi-Criteria Multi-Stakeholder Industrial Projects Prioritization in Gaza Strip. Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering, 38(5), 1217-1227.
Aghazadeh, H., Mohammadi, M., Zadbar, H. (2019). Identifying and Comparing the Priority of Commercialization Services Required for Growing and Developing Companies Based in Tehran University Science and Technology Park. Industrial Management Journal, 10(4), 525-550. (in Persian)
Ahmad, W.N.K.W., Rezaei, J., Sadaghiani, S. & Tavasszy, L.A. (2017). Evaluation of the External Forces Affecting the Sustainability of Oil and Gas Supply Chain Using Best Worst Method. Journal of Cleaner Production, 153, 242-252.
Ahmadi, H.B., Kusi-Sarpong, S., Rezaei, J. (2017). Assessing the Social Sustainability of Supply Chains Using Best Worst Method. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 126, 99-106.
Azimi, N., Barkhordari Doorbash, S. (2010). Identifying the Roots of Knowledge-based Economy (1st Ed.). Tehran: National Research Institute for Science Policy Press. 
(in Persian)
Bai, H., Zhan, Z. (2011). An IT Project Selection Method Based on Fuzzy Analytic Network Process. International Conference on System Science, Engineering Design and Manufacturing Informatization. ICSEM 2011. China, 22-23 October.
Baysal, M.E., Kaya, İ., Kahraman, C., Sarucan, A. & Engin, O. (2015). A Two Phased Fuzzy Methodology for Selection among Municipal Projects. Technological and Economic Development of Economy, 21(3), 405-422.
Chatterjee, K., Hossain, S.A., Kar, S. (2018). Prioritization of Project Proposals in Portfolio Management Using Fuzzy AHP. OPSEARCH, 55(2), 478-501.
Chiang, T., Che, Z.H. (2010). A Fuzzy Robust Evaluation Model for Selecting and Ranking NPD Projects Using Bayesian Belief Network and Weight-Restricted DEA. Expert Systems with Applications, 37(11), 7408–7418.
Chitsaz, N., Azarnivand A. (2016). Water Scarcity Management in Arid Regions Based on An Extended Multiple Criteria Technique. Water Resources Management, 31(1), 233-250.
Davoudpour, H., Rezaee, S., Ashrafi, M. (2012). Developing a framework for renewable technology portfolio selection. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 16(6), 4291-4297.
Fallh Lajimi, H.R., Arab, A.R., Bahramzadeh, H. (2017). Investigate the Barriers of Implementation of Green Supply Chain in Mazandaran Steel Industry with a Combined Approach BSC/BWM. Industrial Management Journal, 8(4), 653-684. (in Persian)
Ghazinoory, S., Ghazinoori, S. (2014). Science, Technology and Innovation Policy Making; An Introduction (2nd Ed.). Tehran: Tarbiat Modares University Press. (in Persian)
Gupta, H., Barua, M.K. (2016). Identifying Enablers of Technological Innovation for Indian MSMEs Using Best–Worst Multi Criteria Decision Making Method, Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 107, 69-79.
Gupta, H., Barua, M.K. (2017). Supplier Selection Among SMEs on the Basis of Their Green Innovation Ability Using BWM And Fuzzy TOPSIS. Journal of Cleaner Production, 152, 242-258.
Habibi, A., Adnvar, M. (2017). Structural Equation Modeling and Factor Analysis (6th Ed). Tehran: Academic Center for Education, Culture and Research Press. (in Persian)
Jafarnejad, A., Yousefi Zenouz, R. (2009). Proposing a Fuzzy Risk Rating Model in PetroPars Drilling Projects. Industrial Management Journal, 1(1), 21-38. (in Persian)
Kakwan, Sh., Modiri, M. (2019). Ranking Solutions to Overcome Barriers to the Adoption of Knowledge Management in the Supply Chain Considering a Combined Fuzzy Decision-Making Approach (Case Study: SAPCO Company). Industrial Management Journal, 10(4), 651-676. (in Persian)
Karaveg, C., Thawesaengskulthai, N., Chandrachai, A. (2015). A Combined Technique Using SEM And TOPSIS For the Commercialization Capability Of R&D Project Evaluation. Decision Science Letters, 4(3), 379-396.
Keyghobadi, M., Malekifar, F., Fathollahi, H. (2015). Knowledge-based Economy and New Growth Theory, with Global Profile of Science and Technology Policy in 52 Countries (1st Ed.). Tehran: Ayandepajooh Press. (in Persian)
Khatami Firoozabadi, S.M.A., Olfat, L., Amiri, M., & Sharifi, H. (2017). Prioritizing Supply Chain Complexity Drivers using Fuzzy Hierarchical Analytical Process. Industrial Management Journal, 9(1), 79-102. (in Persian)
Khodayari, M., Abdollahzadeh, S. (2018). Proposing an Approach to Determine the Appropriate Multi-product Preventive and Maintenance Policies Using Simulation and MCDM. Industrial Management Journal, 10(2), 279-296. (in Persian)
Mohanty, R.P., Agarwal, R., Choudhury, A.K. & Tiwari, M. K. (2005). A Fuzzy ANP-Based Approach to R&D Project Selection: A Case Study. International Journal of Production Research, 43(24), 5199-5216.
Rezaei, J. (2015). Best-Worst Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Method. Omega, 53, 49-57.
Rezaei, J., Nispeling, T., Sarkis, J. & Tavasszy, L. (2016). A Supplier Selection Life Cycle Approach Integrating Traditional and Environmental Criteria Using the Best Worst Method. Journal of Cleaner Production, 135, 577-588.
Rezaei, J., Wang, J., Tavasszy, L. (2015). Linking Supplier Development to Supplier Segmentation Using Best Worst Method. Expert Systems with Applications, 42(23), 9152-9164.
Salimi, N. & Rezaei, J. (2016). Measuring Efficiency of University-Industry Ph. D. Projects Using Best Worst Method. Scientometrics, 109 (3), 1911–1938.
Salimi, N. (2017). Quality Assessment of Scientific Outputs Using the BWM. Scientometrics, 112(1), 195-213.
Salimi, N., & Rezaei, J. (2018). Evaluating Firms’ R&D Performance Using Best Worst Method. Evaluation and Program Planning, 66, 147-155.
Tahmasebi, B.Y., Yazdandoost, F. (2018). An Integrated Framework to Evaluate Resilient-Sustainable Urban Drainage Management Plans Using A Combined-Adaptive MCDM Technique. Water Resources Management, 32(8), 2817-2835.
Thipparat, T., Thaseepetch, T. (2013). An Integrated VIKOR and Fuzzy AHP Method for Assessing a Sustainable Research Project. World Applied Sciences Journal, 22(12), 1729-1738.
Torabi, S. A., Giahi, R., Sahebjamnia, N. (2016). An Enhanced Risk Assessment Framework for Business Continuity Management Systems. Safety Science, 89, 201-218.
Vinodh S., Swarnakar. (2015). Lean Six Sigma Project Selection Using Hybrid Approach Based on Fuzzy DEMATEL–ANP–TOPSIS. International Journal of Lean Six Sigma, 6(4), 313-338.
Wang, F.K., Hsu, C.H., Tzeng, G.H. (2014). Applying a Hybrid MCDM Model FOR Six Sigma Project Selection. Mathematical Problems in Engineering, 2014, 1-14.
Yu, O.S. (2007). Technology Portfolio Planning and Management; Practical Concepts and Tools. USA: Springer Science & Business Media.